Well, it appears that Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story may not be quite the same level of hit that Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story was for Netflix. While it was at the #1 spot in Netflix’s top 10 list for over a week, it has now been dethroned by a new, far better series, the romantic comedy Nobody Wants This.

Erik and Lyle Menendez's murder case was explored in many TV shows and documentaries over the years — including Ryan Murphy's 'Monsters'

Here's what really happened in the Menendez brothers' murders versus what was fictionalized in the Netflix series